Zurich, Switzerland re-tenders 100 electric buses
Zurich public transport operator VBZ is preparing to issue a new procurement for up to 100 battery-electric buses, with an expected investment of CHF 140 million (about EUR 150 million…


Zurich public transport operator VBZ is preparing a new procurement for up to 100 battery-electric buses, with an estimated investment of CHF 140 million (about EUR 150 million). Manufacturers may also voluntarily submit bids for up to 100 trolleybuses, estimated at CHF 160 million (about EUR 172 million).
VBZ could simply have used its existing framework agreements to order more vehicles from Hess and MAN, but chose to hold a new public tender instead. Bus electrification in Europe is moving from adoption into a knockout stage.
The bar for electrification shifts from specs to reliability
VBZ was very clear about its reasons: it is dissatisfied with its current suppliers.
Hess: delivery delays running to months, plus in-service problems with heating/ventilation, the powertrain and automatic pantograph raising and lowering.
MAN: recurring problems with doors, chassis and heating systems.
Problems like these directly cut vehicle availability and lengthen repair times, dragging operators into a vicious circle of too few spare vehicles, disrupted services, and rising complaints and costs. In public transport, stability matters above all.
Framework agreements are no longer a safety net; operating KPIs come first
VBZ also said it delayed the procurement by several months to give the two manufacturers a chance to improve. Had the improvements worked, it could have exercised the follow-on options in the framework agreements, but the suppliers ultimately fell short. This shows that as e-buses reach scale, operators would rather re-tender to bring competitive pressure back to the supply side, especially on key points such as delivery cadence, winter thermal management, reliability of high-wear components and system-level functions.
Running battery-electric and trolleybus in parallel is the pragmatic choice
By tendering for battery-electric buses while leaving room for trolleybus bids, VBZ is essentially optimising the whole system: where charging makes sense and where existing overhead lines can boost efficiency, both may coexist.
Europe's bus market is not a vehicle sales market but an operations market. The keywords for the next phase of competition will be harsher: predictable delivery, verifiable reliability, after-sales and spare parts support, and closed-loop capability in software and electrical systems.