Skip to main content
Overseas car markets · Chinese automakers going global
中
Latest updates
Research
Original research
Data
Regulations
Competitors
Overseas media sentiment
Public procurement
Follow our WeChat account RSS
Commercial vehicles

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y

· 4 min read · AutoMusic Editorial
NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y

Calculations published by German comparison platform Verivox on Nov 13 show that annual comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 costs 60% more than for the Tesla Model Y, the Leapmotor T03 33% more than the Fiat 500e, and the MG4 12% more than the Volkswagen ID.3. Much of the gap comes from vehicle classification: new models are initially rated high, ratings are reassessed annually based on claims data, and initial ratings for new Chinese-brand models are already falling.

Eight model comparisons

Verivox's table covers 8 model pairs: Chinese brands are more expensive in 5 and cheaper in 3. The NIO EL6's annual premium is EUR 1,942 versus EUR 1,213 for the Model Y, a gap of EUR 729; the gaps for the Leapmotor T03 and SAIC Motor's MG4 are EUR 199 and EUR 93 respectively. All premiums include third-party liability cover. The widest gap is in PHEVs: the BYD Seal U DM-i costs 98% more than the Škoda Kodiaq hybrid. The Great Wall Ora 03, by contrast, is 7% cheaper than the Peugeot e-308. The calculation uses a single policyholder profile: Berlin, aged 45, 12,000 km a year, 15 years claims-free. These are quotes for 8 model pairs for one policyholder; Chinese brands are not uniformly more expensive.

Gap between model classes

Each year the German Insurance Association (GDV) assigns every model a rating class based on claims and repair costs over the previous three years. Comprehensive cover runs from class 10 to 34, and the higher the class, the higher the premium. New models have no claims history, so their first rating can only be estimated from technical risk. In 2027, the EL6 was rated class 29 and the Model Y class 22. The T03 was rated class 22 and the 500e class 16. Verivox estimates that each step up in comprehensive class raises premiums by about 4% on average. On that average, a rough calculation puts 7 classes at about 30%, equal to half the NIO EL6 gap. The SAIC MG4 and the Volkswagen ID.3 are both class 19, yet premiums are still 12% higher.

Insurance class explains most of the price gap for the T03 and about half of the gap for the EL6, but none of the gap for the MG4. The rest comes from each insurer's own pricing.

Rating trends

The Allianz Center for Technology looked at new models launched in Germany since 2024. The average initial type class of Chinese brands fell from 28.34 to 26.83, while that of European brands rose from 25.29 to 25.75, narrowing the gap from 3 classes to about 1. The comparison uses the initial type class of the models launched each year. Allianz attributes the shift for European brands to rising repair and parts costs. MG's approach is to keep parts prices stable and repair rather than replace wherever possible.

Automakers can influence insurance group ratings through parts prices and repair methods. The MG4 is already in the same group as the ID.3, while the ORA 03 is 3 groups below the e-308.

Purchase cost comparison

The Leapmotor T03 starts at EUR 18900 in Germany and the 500e at EUR 25990, a gap of EUR 7090; at an extra EUR 199 a year in premiums, it would take more than 30 years to offset that price difference. For private buyers, the premium gap is far smaller than the price gap. Fleets and leasing companies choose vehicles on total cost of ownership, of which insurance is one item; Allianz says Volkswagen Group models are classified on average 1 to 2 classes lower than their rivals in the same segment.

For Chinese brands, high initial classification is a cost of bringing new models into Germany; classes come down only if actual claims and repair costs prove lower than estimated.

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 1

Image source: BYD Europe (byd.com/eu).

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 2

Image source: BYD Europe (byd.com/eu).

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 3

Image: GWM.

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 4

Image source: Leapmotor Deutschland (leapmotor.net).

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 5

Image source: Leapmotor Deutschland (leapmotor.net).

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 6

Image: MG Motor.

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 7

Image: Tesla.

Comprehensive insurance for the NIO EL6 in Germany costs 60% more than for the Model Y: figure 8

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 9

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 10

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 11

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 12

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 13

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 14

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 15

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 16

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 17

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 18

NIO EL6 comprehensive insurance in Germany costs 60% more than Model Y: chart 19

Source: Chart by AutoMusic based on the public sources listed in the article; first published on the AutoMusic WeChat account.

Back to top