JLR v BYD over Tai 7: preservation order withdrawn, infringement claim pending
The UK's Autocar reported on Nov 13 that JLR's chief executive, speaking on a press call, commented publicly for the first time on the dispute with BYD over the Tai 7, saying the company "will not accept infringement of our intellectual property" and will do everything it can to protect it. On Nov 11, a court in The Hague revoked the evidence seizure JLR had obtained at BYD's Dutch offices. JLR thus lost in the evidence-gathering proceedings; whether the Tai 7 copies the Land Rover Defender has not yet been heard. According to the report, the case is expected to go to a hearing later this month.
Lawsuit filed in the Netherlands
BYD's European headquarters is in the Netherlands, so the cases are being heard by Dutch courts. JLR has filed two summary proceedings: the Hague court is hearing the EU design rights dispute, and the Rotterdam court the copyright and passing-off dispute. In both, JLR seeks an injunction against infringement and access to materials seized in month 8. The Tai 7 is not sold in the EU but is open for orders in the UK, priced from GBP 47995. That is GBP 20470, or about 30%, less than the seven-seat Defender 110. Deliveries begin in Jan 2027.
The rulings record that JLR sought to block the Tai 7 from launching in the EU; UK deliveries fall outside the scope of the two proceedings
Grounds for lifting the preservation order
The preliminary relief judge at the court in The Hague issued a judgment on Nov 11 and a corrected judgment on the 12th. On Aug 24, bailiffs gathered evidence at two offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp and were permitted to copy electronic data dating from Aug 2025 using nine search terms such as "Ti7" and "Defender", covering launch plans, financials, supply chain and design files. The judge found that JLR had not argued it needed this material to prove infringement either, and that since the Ti7 is not sold in the EU, there is as yet no loss. JLR must order the data destroyed within 24 hours of service of the judgment, or pay EUR 50,000 for each hour of delay, capped at EUR 500,000.
The second argument assumes the Tai 7 is not on sale in the EU; once it goes on sale, that argument changes, while the first is unaffected.
Court costs and fines
The corrected judgment changes who bears the litigation costs: the original judgment wrongly named BYD, and it now requires JLR to pay EUR 25,376.57. Of this, EUR 18,000 is legal fees, which the court allowed up to the guideline cap for ordinary summary IP proceedings. BYD had claimed EUR 60,917 and was awarded about 30%. In September JLR had demanded a EUR 500,000 penalty, alleging BYD failed to cooperate with evidence collection. The judge found that BYD had met its duty to cooperate and ordered enforcement to stop. The sums involved are small. With the materials destroyed, JLR's requests to access them in two infringement proceedings also come to nothing.
European sales plan
JLR has won a case like this before. In 2019, Beijing's Chaoyang District Court found that an SUV from JMC's Landwind brand copied 5 features of a JLR model, ruled that this was unfair competition, and ordered production and sales to stop. The situation then and BYD's situation now are not comparable.
If either proceeding results in an injunction, the Tai 7's EU launch plans would be affected. Automakers planning to bring similar-looking models into the EU should screen for design rights and copyright before announcing sales plans.

Image: BYD.

Image: BYD.

Image: JLR Media Centre.

Image: JLR.














Source: Chart by AutoMusic based on the public sources listed in the article; first published on the AutoMusic WeChat account.