Skip to main content
Overseas car markets · Chinese automakers going global
中
Latest updates
Research
Original research
Data
Regulations
Competitors
Overseas media sentiment
Public procurement
Follow our WeChat account RSS
Commercial vehicles

MAN scales back hydrogen investment: hydrogen prices and supply

According to an exclusive report by Hydrogen Insight on Nov 16, MAN Truck & Bus will stop investing in hydrogen beyond its existing pilots, saying hydrogen trucks and buses currently have "no viable business model".

· 3 min read · AutoMusic Editorial
MAN scales back hydrogen investment: hydrogen prices and supply

According to an exclusive Hydrogen Insight report on Nov 16, MAN Truck & Bus will stop hydrogen investment beyond its existing pilots, saying hydrogen trucks and buses currently have "no viable business model". At the time of writing, MAN and its parent Traton had not issued a statement. Publicly available data show that MAN's hydrogen vehicles have already been built; commercial operation is held back first and foremost by hydrogen prices and refueling supply.

Existing hydrogen models

The hTGX hydrogen combustion truck was launched in Apr 2024, with an initial small run of about 200 units planned. MAN said on the 12th of this month that leasing company hylane is already operating two in the Netherlands. MAN did not say whether it will continue taking orders for the hTGX. The fuel cell route is the Bayernflotte project funded by the German state of Bavaria: EUR 8.5 million was granted in 2022, and the trucks were originally to be delivered to five customers in mid-2024 for a one-year trial each. It was not until the end of July this year that three trucks were handed to LoadFox, MAN's own haulage company, for a three-month trial. The three trucks carry 36 kg of hydrogen, consume 7 to 8 kg per 100 km and have a range of 450 to 500 km. The pilot is so far limited to internal operations, and what independent customers are willing to pay has yet to be tested.

Hydrogen prices and refueling stations

Based on a fuel cell truck's hydrogen consumption, and using the net price of about €8/kg that hylane customers negotiated at designated stations, fuel costs €56–64 per 100 km. At €15/kg, it costs €105–120. h2-international puts a diesel truck at about 30 litres per 100 km, for a fuel cost of about €49.

Germany had about 80 public hydrogen stations two years ago; by the start of this year only about 50 remained.

MAN set out the preconditions back in 2022: green hydrogen and supporting infrastructure are unlikely to be sufficient until well after 2030, and for intensively operated commercial vehicles, fuel is the largest share of total cost of ownership. For fleets, this fuel cost gap depends on the hydrogen price, which OEMs can hardly bring down on their own.

BEV as the core product line

MAN is focusing on the eTGX and eTGS. The eTGX newly leased by hylane has up to 534 kWh of battery capacity, up to 570 km of range, and an optional Megawatt Charging System (MCS) of up to 750 kW.

MAN sold 805 BEV trucks in the first three quarters, about 1.7% of its 47385 truck sales in the same period.

Daimler Truck delays series production: it plans a small batch of 100 fuel-cell tractors, with customer deliveries starting at year-end; series production has been pushed back from 2027 to the early 2030s because the hydrogen refueling network is expanding more slowly than expected.

For buyers, until hydrogen falls to about €6–7 per kg and fuel costs reach parity with diesel, zero-emission heavy trucks will be mainly battery-electric, and hydrogen models are better suited to pilot projects.

Sources: Hydrogen Insight, MAN press release, Traton, electrive, h2-international

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: image 1

Image source: MAN Truck & Bus.

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: image 2

Image source: MAN Truck & Bus.

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: image 3

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: image 4

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: image 5

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 6

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 7

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 8

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 9

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 10

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 11

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 12

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 13

MAN scales back hydrogen investment over hydrogen prices and supply: chart 14

Source: Chart by AutoMusic based on the public sources listed in the article; first published on the AutoMusic WeChat account.

Sources

Back to top