↑Back to top
AutoMusic overseas media monitoring · 2026-10-17 to 11-14 Overseas reputation, issue 2 · Nine Chinese automakers

Negative after-sales reviews are mounting, and Europe is no exception

Excluding official and dealer-generated content, we tracked 48,901 public overseas posts about nine companies: BYD, Chery Group, Geely Auto, SAIC MG, GAC International, Maxus, Foton, Sinotruk and Yutong. Of these, 12,514 came from 25 European countries. Grouped by topic: exterior design drew 2,448 positive and 1,115 negative posts; after-sales service networks drew 584 positive and 1,153 negative, against 319 and 417 in the previous period. This page aggregates data for the nine companies by topic and does not rank them by net sentiment.

Window: 2026-10-17 to 11-14 (GAC: 10-16 to 11-14) 2026-11: remaining markets added by sales volume Previous issue: 2026-09-16 to 10-16
Total overseas discussion, nine brands
0 items
Users, bloggers, media; 12,514 posts from 25 European countries
Service network: 1 positive mentions per negative
0 items
Previous period: 1.3 items; this period: 584 positive, 1,153 negative
Parts and repairs: 1 positive mentions per negative
0 items
Previous period: 2.8 items; this period: 257 positive, 929 negative
User content as share of all discussion
0%
39,110 posts, net sentiment +0.4%; media +15.0%
01 / topics

Positive and negative mentions across 13 topic categories

Each item is classified by the topics it covers; the chart shows the 13 categories with the most combined positive and negative mentions. An item may cover several topics, so topic counts cannot be summed to the total. Grouped into pre-purchase and post-purchase.

More positive than negative (nine brands combined)
Seen at purchase
Design 2.2 : 1Powertrain and driving 1.8 : 1Interior and space 1.7 : 1Price/value 1.7 : 1Range and charging 1.6 : 1Brand reputation 1.5 : 1
Figures are positive : negative mentions. Range and charging was 2.2 : 1 last period, the sharpest decline in this group.
More negative than positive (nine brands combined)
Encountered in use
Resale value 1 : 6.7Parts and repairs 1 : 3.6Delivery and stock 1 : 2.7Quality/reliability 1 : 2.4Service outlets 1: 2.0Crash safety 1 : 1.9Infotainment software 1 : 1.3
After-sales service network was 1 : 1.3 last period, the biggest change; infotainment software and delivery/inventory improved slightly from last period.
Nine combined: positive and negative mentions by topic for 13 topics (2026-10-17 to 11-14)
Unit: mentions · negative on the left, positive on the right
Brand reputation has the most positive and the most negative mentions (positive 4,103, negative 2,766), and most general comments fall into this category. Quality and reliability has 2,969 negative mentions, still the largest single negative topic.
Source: AutoMusic overseas sentiment monitoring (2026-11, supplemented with markets ranked by sales), word-of-mouth basis
02 / Period comparison

Negative share by topic: previous vs. current period

Negative share = negative ÷ (positive + negative); neutral and mixed mentions are excluded from the denominator. This period covers more markets and channels than the last. In the chart below, the current-period side counts only markets monitored last period and excludes the newly added TikTok, Instagram and Facebook (33,240 posts). On a like-for-like basis, the negative share for after-sales outlets was 65%, versus 57% last period.

Negative share of 13 topics, two periods compared: after-sales service network up from 57% to 65%
Unit: % · Grey dots: previous period (2026-09-16 to 10-16); blue / orange dots: current period on the same basis · Dashed line: 50%
The biggest increases were in after-sales service network (+8 percentage points), range and charging (+6) and interior space (+5); parts and repairs and residual value each rose 1–2 percentage points; infotainment software and value for money each fell 5 percentage points.
Data source: AutoMusic overseas media monitoring; nine companies combined, same basis in both issues
Number of companies with mostly positive, mostly negative or insufficient samples on 13 topics (9 companies in total)
Unit: companies · Insufficient sample means fewer than 10 positive and negative items combined for that company on that topic
On exterior, interior and powertrain, all 9 companies drew more positive than negative comments; on price, 8 did. On parts and repairs and on resale value, none of the companies with enough comments drew more positive than negative. On after-sales service network, only Sinotruk did.
Data source: AutoMusic overseas media monitoring, counted company by company
After-sales service outlets
7 / 8 companies mostly negative
Previous edition 5 / 7. New items include service charges, dealer closures, few local outlets and waits for damage assessment.
Parts and repair
7 / 7 companies mostly negative
Last issue: 6 / 6; this issue adds Maxus. Common complaints: waiting for parts, expensive OEM parts, long post-accident repair times.
Exterior design
9 / 9 brands mostly positive
In both editions, all nine companies had more positive than negative mentions.
03 / Europe

25 European countries: 12,514 discussions

This edition fills in searches across the nine markets with sales. The 25 European countries (excluding Russia, Belarus and Turkey) account for about a quarter of all discussion, with net sentiment of +3.6%, versus +3.9% outside Europe. Price perception is better in Europe than outside it, while negative shares for after-sales, parts and residual value are almost identical to those across all markets.

The 8 most-discussed countries in Europe: mention count and net sentiment (2026-10-17 to 11-14)
Net sentiment = (positive − negative) ÷ total items · Unit: % · Item counts in brackets · Nine companies combined
Germany and Poland are both at −9.4%. Germany's aftersales network drew 186 negative and 44 positive mentions, the widest gap of any European country; the UK leans positive overall, but residual value drew 97 negative and 9 positive mentions.
Source: AutoMusic overseas sentiment monitoring (2026-11, supplemented with markets ranked by sales), word-of-mouth basis
Value for money · negative share
28% Europe
Outside Europe: 41%. Europe: 1,151 positive, 456 negative.
After-sales service network · negative share
65% Europe
All markets combined: 66%. Europe: 189 positive, 354 negative.
Resale value/used · negative share
85% Europe
All markets combined: 87%; parts and repairs: Europe 79%, all markets 78%.
04 / follow-up

Recalls, repairs and sales restrictions listed in the first issue

The first issue ended by listing follow-ups on recalls, repairs and sales restrictions. This issue reviews each item against official notices and manufacturer statements. Where no notice was found, we write "no notice found" and do not speculate.

The 3 follow-up items listed in the first edition: progress as of 2026-11-14
In the order listed in the first issue
ItemPrevious statusThis period's progressStatus
Chery Malaysia Omoda 5 rear axle recall and type approvalRecall of 8,878 vehicles; Land Transport Authority suspends type approvalNo announcement of the recall completion rate or lifting of the suspension; the Land Transport Authority said on Oct 11 it would be lifted only once all measures are completed. The rear-axle issue has expanded to recalls in China, South Africa and AustraliaOpen
BYD Australia Shark 6 spare tyre recall32,009 vehicles recalled; spare tire removal advised before repairsBYD has offered free replacement (with an updated spare tyre lift mechanism) since the recall; no public update on repair progress or completion rate seenNo update
Russia restricts sales of specific Foton and other Chinese truck modelsRosstandart sales restriction, Oct 12No announcement of the restrictions being lifted; Rosstandart says they will be lifted once violations are rectified, and the companies concerned have halted sales and are preparing recall plansOpen
Of the three, Chery's rear axle issue changed most in scope: from Malaysia alone to recalls in four markets.
Sources: Road Transport Department Malaysia (2026-10-11); State Administration for Market Regulation; South African Government News Agency; Australian Department of Infrastructure; BYD Australia owner notice (2026-09-15); RIA Novosti (2026-10-12)
05 / The nine brands one by one

Praise, complaints and official records for nine companies

Quality and reliability (positive 1,220, negative 2,969) is the topic with the most negative mentions; among the nine companies, all except Yutong had more negative than positive mentions. About 43% of quality-related negatives came from Chery Group, versus about 60% in the previous issue. Negative items naming companies cover only incidents with official records, and include the manufacturer's response.

Nine companies, 2026-10-17 to 11-14: praise, complaints and official records
Listed in a fixed company order, not a ranking
CompanyPraise centres onComplaints centre onOfficial records this issue
BYDSealion 07, Seagull, Shark 6; UK and Spanish reviews; brand, powertrain, price, rangeAfter-sales and parts (Germany, Thailand, Poland); residual value (Thailand, after a limited-time promotion)BYD Da Tang wheel rim misfitting: BYD says it will inspect and replace free of charge, claims no driving safety risk (China, 2026-11-11)
Chery GroupTiggo 7/9; reviews in Spain and Greece; exterior, priceRear axle issues spreading across several countries; residual values (UK, South Africa)China recall: 53,882 units; South Africa: 23,667 units (20,193 for rear axle); Australia: 7,285 units; Latin NCAP: isolated Tiggo 2 cases
GeelyReviews from Mexico, the UK and Spain; brand, powertrain, designRust protection and paint in Belarus; Boyue L facelift pricing; Xingyuan deliveries in BrazilGeely Brazil confirms some EX2 versions are out of stock; new batch arriving in months 11–12 (statement of 11-03)
MGNew MG4, ZS; reviews in the UK and Spain; price, exteriorResidual values and parts (Poland, Germany); ZS hybrid pricing in Vietnam—
GACAion UT, Aion V; interior, price, rangeRussia: GS8 vehicle condition; Poland: Trumpchi Emkoo pricing and long-term parts supply—
MaxusT70 launch in Peru, Xingji coverageT60 reliability and parts; winter range of electric vans in Poland—
FotonTunland reviews in Australia and South Africa; exteriorQuestions over Tunland pricing and powertrain in Russia, Turkey and BrazilRussia restricts sales of models including the 77N5BJ (10-12); no revocation notice seen
SinotrukHOWO short videos in Vietnam and Indonesia; exterior, brandSITRAK prices and electrical faults in RussiaKano, Nigeria accident (FRSC: suspected brake failure, investigation ongoing)
YutongNew vehicles entering service in Pakistan, the Philippines and Mexico; quality feedback slightly more positiveSeats and exterior in the UK and Colombia; remote access in the Netherlands and NorwayWritten answer to the Dutch parliament (2026-05, still cited in this issue)
For the five passenger car makers, praise centres on specific models, exterior design and price, while complaints concentrate on after-sales, parts and resale value. Samples for the four commercial vehicle makers are small, so their topics are described only.
Source: AutoMusic overseas sentiment monitoring, counted per company; official records from the respective recall, rating and regulatory sources
Chery rear axle-related recalls: 53882 units in China, 20193 in South Africa, 8878 in Malaysia, 7285 in Australia
Unit: vehicles · Rear axle-related only · Recalled models and production batches differ by country, so figures are not additive · Malaysia figure is the first-phase record
China recalled the Tiggo5x and Omoda built between 2022-06-06 and 2023-12-31. South Africa recalled 17,508 Tiggo4 (Tiggo 4 Pro) and 2,685 Omoda C5 vehicles; the same batch also included 3,474 Tiggo8 Pro Max recalled for brake lines, for a total of 23,667 vehicles. Australia recalled the 2023 Omoda 5. In all four markets, the cause points to rear-axle welding.
Data sources: State Administration for Market Regulation recall S2026M0146V (2026-11-06); South African Government News Agency (2026-11-11); Australian Department of Infrastructure REC-006776 (2026-11-13); the 8,878 units in Malaysia are from a Chery Malaysia statement dated 2026-10-14
Oct 11, 2026 to Nov 13: recalls, ratings and accident records
Sort by date
2026-10-11
Malaysia · type approval
The Land Transport Authority said the suspension of the Omoda 5 type approval will be lifted only after all corrective and preventive actions are completed.
2026-10-20
Nigeria · Kano
A HOWO dump truck fully loaded with asphalt rolled backwards into a car, killing 2; the Federal Road Safety Corps suspects brake failure.
2026-10-28
Latin NCAP · Tiggo 2
First results under the new 2026 protocol, still few; adult occupant protection 0%, child occupant protection 0%.
2026-11-06
China · 53,882 units recalled
Tiggo 5x and Omoda: the rear-axle trailing arm and sleeve may be poorly welded; free inspections from Nov 27, with rear axles replaced on affected batches.
2026-11-07
Malaysia · NKVE accident
A wheel came off a Tiggo Cross after a crash; Chery says it was caused by the collision, not a component failure.
2026-11-10
South Africa · 23,667 units recalled
Of these, 20,193 Tiggo4 (Tiggo 4 Pro) and Omoda C5 vehicles are affected by rear axle tube welding, and 3,474 Tiggo8 Pro Max by brake lines. Chery South Africa described the recall as precautionary. The National Consumer Commission said it has opened an investigation into the alleged failure to report the recall.
2026-11-13
Australia · 7,285 vehicles recalled
2023 Omoda 5: rear axle may be insufficiently welded and could crack; Chery says no related cases have occurred locally.
Sources: Road Transport Department Malaysia; BusinessDay; Latin NCAP; State Administration for Market Regulation; Malay Mail; South African Government News Agency; Australian Department of Infrastructure
06 / Who's saying it

Net sentiment by poster and channel

Net sentiment = (positive − negative) ÷ total mentions. Across all nine combined: media +15.0%, influencers +31.6%, users +0.4%. For seven of the nine, media net sentiment is higher than user sentiment; the exceptions are Sinotruk and Yutong.

Nine companies combined, by poster: media +15.0%, bloggers +31.6%, users +0.4%
Unit: % · post counts in brackets
39,110 posts from online users, about 80% of all discussion, so the overall figures are driven mainly by online users.
Source: AutoMusic overseas media monitoring, nine companies combined
Nine companies combined, by channel: YouTube 24316 posts, net sentiment +1.0%; news 6564 items, +14.9%
X-axis: mentions (log scale) · Y-axis: net sentiment % · Only channels with more than 100 mentions
News and X were collected the same way in both periods, with similar readings (news +13.5% → +14.9%, X +8.2% → +7.0%); Reddit turned from positive to negative.
Data source: AutoMusic overseas sentiment monitoring
07 / precedent

Toyota 2009–2014: recalls, fines and settlements

Toyota carried out large-scale recalls in the US over floor mats trapping accelerator pedals and pedals slow to return. A 2011 NHTSA report said Toyota had recalled more than seven million vehicles over unintended acceleration. The fines and settlements targeted delayed reporting and concealment, not the recalls themselves.

Toyota recall case: maximum civil penalty of USD 16.375 million in 2010; USD 1.2 billion settlement in 2014
USD million · log scale
The 2014 settlement is about 73 times the 2010 fine; both stemmed from disclosure issues.
Sources: US Department of Transportation press release 59-10 (2010-04-05); US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York (2014-03-19)
Toyota precedent vs. this recall
Sort by date
2009-09-29US DOT says Toyota knew of the accelerator pedal defect by this date at the latest; regulations require reporting within 5 business days
2010-04-05US Department of Transportation seeks maximum civil penalty of $16.375 million
2014-03-19In a USD 1.2 billion deferred prosecution agreement, Toyota admitted concealing information and misleading consumers about two unintended acceleration safety issues
This period's comparisonRegulators in three markets have published the scope of Chery's rear axle recall; South Africa's National Consumer Commission has opened an investigation into an allegedly unreported recall
Sources: US Department of Transportation; US Department of Justice; South African Government News Agency
08 / basis

Data definitions and quick reference

Data from AutoMusic overseas media monitoring; 2026-11 version with gaps filled by sales market.

How this data is collected and how to read it
AutoMusic overseas sentiment monitoring: methodology
Data collectionSearch terms are set by brand and market. Sources include YouTube videos and comments, TikTok, X, Reddit, Instagram, Facebook, Google News and Thailand's Pantip. This issue adds TikTok, Instagram and Facebook, changes the YouTube search method, and fills in Europe, Latin America, the Middle East and Asia-Pacific to cover all nine markets with sales. Russia's Drive2 could not be accessed this issue.
Sentiment basisCounts only users, bloggers and media; official accounts and dealers' own content listed separately and excluded; Google Maps store reviews listed separately and excluded
MethodThe model tags sentiment, model and topic for each entry; manual verification under way, accuracy not yet published
Period-on-period comparisonBoth markets and channels have expanded, so counts are not compared by direct subtraction. The period-on-period comparison covers only markets monitored in the previous period and excludes new channels (33,240). Negative share for after-sales outlets: 65% (previous period: 57%)
ConcentrationWhere more than half of a market's negative posts come from the same main thread, they are treated as a single event; the interval does not account for correlation between comments under the same main thread.
Approach on this pageNine companies grouped by topic, counting positive and negative mentions for each; net sentiment per company is not shown and companies are not ranked
Source: AutoMusic overseas sentiment monitoring methodology page
Data reference: figures, definitions and sources on this page
Listed in page order
Mentions across nine brandsTotal 48,901 items: BYD 14,424, Chery Group 12,664, Geely 6,995, MG 6,163, GAC 4,693, Maxus 632, Foton 1,285, Sinotruk 1,175, Yutong 870 · Window 2026-10-17 to 11-14 (GAC 10-16 to 11-14)
Topics at purchaseExterior design positive 2,448 / negative 1,115; interior space 2,158 / 1,278; powertrain and driving 2,902 / 1,590; range and charging 1,654 / 1,036; price and value 3,341 / 1,961; brand reputation 4,103 / 2,766
Topics after purchaseAfter-sales network: positive 584 / negative 1,153; parts and repairs 257 / 929; resale value 128 / 854; infotainment software 810 / 1,061; delivery and stock 138 / 369
Quality and safetyQuality and reliability: positive 1,220 / negative 2,969 (negatives outnumber positives at 8 of 9 companies); safety and crash: 410 / 763 (negatives outnumber positives at 4 of the 7 companies with enough mentions)
Previous-period comparisonAfter-sales service network 319 / 417; parts and repairs 123 / 347; residual value and used cars 45 / 250; infotainment software 395 / 609; delivery and inventory 49 / 176; range and charging 964 / 433 (2026-09-16 to 10-16); this period on the same basis: after-sales service network 423 / 791, parts and repairs 208 / 659, residual value and used cars 103 / 622
Posted byMedia +15.0% (8,374 posts); influencers +31.6% (1,417 posts); users +0.4% (39,110 posts)
Europe25 countries, 12,514 posts, +3.6%: UK 2,585 +7.9%, Germany 2,197 −9.4%, Poland 1,851 −9.4%, Spain 1,178 +20.8%; negative share: price 28%, aftersales 65%, parts 79%, resale value 85%
ChannelYouTube +1.0% (24,316); TikTok +4.1% (8,604); News +14.9% (6,564); X +7.0% (3,983); Reddit −4.7% (3,780); Instagram +16.9% (851); Facebook +4.8% (395); Pantip +12.7% (276); Telegram +1.6% (125)
Recalls and ratingsChery: China 53,882 units (SAMR 2026-11-06), South Africa 23,667 units, of which rear axle 20,193 units (NCC, 2026-11-10), Australia 7,285 units (REC-006776, 2026-11-13); Latin NCAP Tiggo 2 isolated cases (2026-10-28); BYD Tang wheel rim mis-fitment statement (2026-11-11); Geely Xingyuan stock shortage statement in Brazil (2026-11-03); Rosstandart sales restriction (2026-10-12, no revocation seen)
PrecedentToyota: US Department of Transportation sought the maximum civil penalty of $16.375 million (2010-04-05); US Department of Justice $1.2 billion deferred prosecution agreement (2014-03-19)
Author's calculationsPositive-to-negative ratios, negative shares, company counts, European country breakdowns and like-for-like comparisons for each topic are all calculated from item-level data
Sources: AutoMusic overseas media monitoring and the listed recall, rating and regulatory sources