JLR CEO PB Balaji spoke publicly about the dispute for the first time on Nov 13. Based on the original text of The Hague court's judgment, this page sets out the scope of the preservation order, the two grounds for lifting it, the breakdown of legal costs and the penalty arrangements; compares the UK starting prices of the Tai 7 and the Land Rover Defender; and lists the two summary proceedings still pending and earlier comparable rulings.
BYD Europe B.V. is based in Schiedam and BYD Nederland B.V. in Hoofddorp. In 8, JLR first applied to the court in The Hague for evidence preservation, then filed summary proceedings in both The Hague and Rotterdam. The Nov 11 judgment deals only with BYD's objection to the preservation order; paragraph 3.11 of the judgment lists the case numbers of the other two proceedings.
| Procedure | Court and case number | Filed by | Matter in dispute | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Objection to injunction | Hague District Court C/09/713312 | BYD | Lift the evidence seizure ordered in 8; confirm that no penalty is owed for cooperating with evidence collection | Judgment Nov 11, corrected on the 12th |
| Design rights | Hague District Court C/09/712003 | JLR | Whether the Tai 7 infringes the Defender's EU design rights; request for an injunction against infringement | Pending review |
| Copyright and counterfeiting | Rotterdam District Court C/10/725869 | JLR | Whether the Tai 7 infringes the Defender's copyright and constitutes passing off; seeks an injunction and access to the preserved materials | Pending review |
On Aug 14, the court in The Hague allowed JLR to seize evidence from BYD, and bailiffs carried out the seizure in Schiedam and Hoofddorp on Aug 24. On Sep 29, BYD sued to have the seizure lifted, arguing that the search terms and document categories were too broad and that large amounts of unrelated commercial material had been copied. The judge did not rule on whether the scope was too broad. Instead, the judge lifted the seizure in full on the grounds that it was unnecessary.
| What JLR uses it for | Judge's findings |
|---|---|
| Proves the Tai 7 infringes the Defender's EU design rights | JLR did not argue in its application that it needed these documents to prove infringement, so preservation of this item was unnecessary |
| Determine the scope of infringement and damages | Neither side disputes that BYD does not currently sell the Tai 7 in the EU; the alleged threat of infringement has not yet caused any losses |
| To be used for calculation after a future court win | A legal relationship that may arise in the future is insufficient grounds for preservation measures now |
| Target | JLR's position | Judge's findings |
|---|---|---|
| Laptop | At 12:20 the bailiff asked 4 employees to bring their computers to a meeting room; they did not arrive until 15:10 | The duty to cooperate does not include handing over physical equipment within a set deadline |
| Local network-attached storage (NAS) | Accounts not opened in time | The equipment is on site in Hoofddorp, so bailiffs can remove it directly without BYD's cooperation |
| Microsoft 365 | Access was granted too late and was interrupted on Aug 27–28 | Access must be granted by staff in China; granted at 17:15; restored shortly after the interruption |
| WeCom | Did not provide sufficient access | BYD has provided the username and password; the inability to export data is a technical limitation |
Items 5.3 and 5.4 of the operative part of the Nov 11 judgment assigned litigation costs and late-payment interest to BYD. BYD wrote to the court that day requesting a correction; on Nov 12, JLR replied that it did not object, and the court issued a corrected judgment the same day, changing the liable party for both items to JLR. The original judgment has been removed from the Dutch judiciary's public database.
| Payment | Who is claiming against whom | Basis | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penalty tied to evidence preservation | JLR to BYD | Aug 14 interim order: €50,000 per hour for non-compliance, capped at €500,000 | The judge found that BYD had fulfilled its duty to cooperate and owed no penalty |
| Penalty for late destruction | BYD to JLR | Nov 11 ruling: €50,000 per hour, capped at €500,000 | Would not have been incurred had JLR arranged destruction on schedule |
| Ongoing penalty payments | BYD to JLR | Nov 11 ruling: EUR 500,000 per enforcement action | Not incurred if JLR stops pursuing payment |
PB Balaji said on a press call on Nov 13 that JLR does not accept infringement of its intellectual property and will do everything it can to protect it. He added that the evidence secured under the preservation order is no longer needed, because BYD has announced its European sales plan for the Tai 7. In the same report, Autocar listed several earlier cases in which European carmakers sued Chinese carmakers for copying vehicle designs. The table below adds the rulings reported at the time.
| Year | Plaintiff and models | Defendant and models | Court | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 | BMW X5 | Shuanghuan CEO | Munich court | Import into Germany prohibited |
| 2008 | Fiat Panda | Great Wall Peri | Court of Turin | Import into Europe banned; fine of EUR 15,000 for the first vehicle already imported and EUR 50,000 for each one thereafter |
| 2019 | JLR Range Rover Evoque | JMC Landwind X7 | Beijing Chaoyang District Court | Unfair competition case: court found 5 features were copied, causing consumer confusion, and ordered a halt to production, sales and promotion, plus damages |
| 2020 | JLR classic Defender | Ineos Grenadier | — | JLR failed to block the vehicle's sale |
| Model | Markets | Starting price |
|---|---|---|
| Land Rover Defender | China | approx. 82,500 |
| Fangchengbao Tai 7 | United Kingdom | 47,995 |
| BAIC Xingtan 5X | China | approx. 15,000 |