↑Back to top
Netherlands · IP litigation · BYD Tai 7 Public information as of 2026-11-14

JLR v BYD over the Tai 7: Hague court lifts evidence seizure on Nov 11, corrects which party bears costs on the 12th

JLR CEO PB Balaji spoke publicly about the dispute for the first time on Nov 13. Based on the original text of The Hague court's judgment, this page sets out the scope of the preservation order, the two grounds for lifting it, the breakdown of legal costs and the penalty arrangements; compares the UK starting prices of the Tai 7 and the Land Rover Defender; and lists the two summary proceedings still pending and earlier comparable rulings.

Hague District Court corrected judgment ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33456 · 2026-11-12 Autocar · 2026-11-13 electrive.net · 2026-11-14 BYD UK press release · 2026-07-31
Legal costs JLR must pay
0 EUR
Judgment amount EUR 25,376.57, of which EUR 18,000 in legal fees
Search terms listed in the preservation order
0 items
Covers material since Aug 1, 2025
Hearing to judgment
0 days
Hearing Oct 14, ruling Nov 11
Tai 7 UK starting price below the seven-seat Defender 110
0%
Approximate; £47,995 vs £68,465
01 / Venue of litigation

All three proceedings are in the Netherlands; only the objection to the attachment has been decided

BYD Europe B.V. is based in Schiedam and BYD Nederland B.V. in Hoofddorp. In 8, JLR first applied to the court in The Hague for evidence preservation, then filed summary proceedings in both The Hague and Rotterdam. The Nov 11 judgment deals only with BYD's objection to the preservation order; paragraph 3.11 of the judgment lists the case numbers of the other two proceedings.

Official images of the Fangchengbao Tai 7 and Land Rover Defender, with UK starting prices for both
Fangchengbao Tai 7 (exported as Ti7) and Land Rover Defender. Image sources: BYD website, JLR Media Centre
Three JLR v BYD proceedings in the Netherlands: 1 decided, 2 pending
Compiled from the judgment · Blue shading marks proceedings decided on Nov 11
ProcedureCourt and case numberFiled byMatter in disputeStatus
Objection to injunctionHague District Court C/09/713312BYDLift the evidence seizure ordered in 8; confirm that no penalty is owed for cooperating with evidence collectionJudgment Nov 11, corrected on the 12th
Design rightsHague District Court C/09/712003JLRWhether the Tai 7 infringes the Defender's EU design rights; request for an injunction against infringementPending review
Copyright and counterfeitingRotterdam District Court C/10/725869JLRWhether the Tai 7 infringes the Defender's copyright and constitutes passing off; seeks an injunction and access to the preserved materialsPending review
Source: corrected judgment of The Hague District Court, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33456, paragraph 3.11 and footnotes 2 and 3
▸ Autocar reported on Nov 13 that the case is expected in court later in 11, without saying which case or giving a date.
UK starting prices: Tai 7 £47,995, seven-seat Defender 110 £68,465
GBP · Tai 7: the Excellence AWD seven-seater on sale in the UK
Sources: BYD UK press release, 2026-07-31; electrive.net, 2026-11-14
▸ The gap is £20,470, or 29.9% of the Defender's starting price. Tai 7 pre-orders opened Jul 31, it reached showrooms in month 11, and deliveries begin Jan 2027.
Tai 7 launch milestones: China in Sep 2025, UK deliveries in Jan 2027
Compiled from public information
2025-09
Sold in China under the Fangchengbao brand
2026-07-31
BYD UK announces pricing and specs, opens orders
2026-10-08
BYD Europe chief says in video that the Tai 7 has arrived in the UK
2026-11
Arrives in UK showrooms
2027-01
UK deliveries begin
Source: electrive.net; BYD UK press release; Hague court judgment, para. 3.3
▸ The judgment found that the Tai 7 has never been sold in the EU. Since Brexit, the UK is outside the scope of EU design rights.
02 / Injunction lifted

Scope of the injunction and the two grounds for revocation

On Aug 14, the court in The Hague allowed JLR to seize evidence from BYD, and bailiffs carried out the seizure in Schiedam and Hoofddorp on Aug 24. On Sep 29, BYD sued to have the seizure lifted, arguing that the search terms and document categories were too broad and that large amounts of unrelated commercial material had been copied. The judge did not rule on whether the scope was too broad. Instead, the judge lifted the seizure in full on the grounds that it was unnecessary.

Scope of the Aug 14 preservation order
Judgment, paragraphs 3.4 to 3.6
Search terms
9 items
Includes model name, brand name and the Defender's internal code name
Document type
4 categories
Launch and sales, finance, internal approval and production, design and development
Time range
2025-08-01 onward
One month before the Ti7 launch in China
Penalty for non-compliance
50,000 euros per hour
Starts two hours after the bailiff's demand, capped at €500,000
Ti7T i 7Tai 7Titanium 7Leopard 7DefenderLand RoverJaguar Land RoverL663
Source: Hague District Court corrected judgment ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33456
Judge's two grounds for lifting the injunction
Judgment, paragraphs 5.7 to 5.10
What JLR uses it forJudge's findings
Proves the Tai 7 infringes the Defender's EU design rightsJLR did not argue in its application that it needed these documents to prove infringement, so preservation of this item was unnecessary
Determine the scope of infringement and damagesNeither side disputes that BYD does not currently sell the Tai 7 in the EU; the alleged threat of infringement has not yet caused any losses
To be used for calculation after a future court winA legal relationship that may arise in the future is insufficient grounds for preservation measures now
Source: Hague District Court corrected judgment ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33456
▸ The ruling did not assess whether the Tai 7 and the Defender are similar. The judge also did not address BYD's alternative claim that the scope was too broad.
Time between stages of the seizure challenge: 28 days from hearing to judgment, 1 days from judgment to correction
Days · Aug 14, 2026 to Nov 12, 90 days in total
Source: dates listed in the Hague court's corrected judgment; intervals calculated by AutoMusic
▸ The longest gap was the 36 days between execution of the seizure order and BYD filing suit, during which the parties exchanged multiple emails over the bailiff's report and penalties.
Penalty for failing to destroy on time: EUR 50,000 per hour, reaching the EUR 500,000 cap at hour 10
EUR 10,000 · accrues from 24 hours after service of the judgment
Source: Hague court corrected judgment, para. 6.1; cumulative curve calculated here at €50,000 per hour
▸ JLR must instruct the bailiff or custodian to destroy the material within 24 hours of being served the judgment, and must give BYD written confirmation within 24 hours of the destruction.
Aug 24: the four categories of systems covered by evidence-taking and the judge's ruling on the duty to cooperate
On Sep 4 JLR cited this to demand a EUR 500,000 penalty · Judgment paras. 5.15–5.22
TargetJLR's positionJudge's findings
LaptopAt 12:20 the bailiff asked 4 employees to bring their computers to a meeting room; they did not arrive until 15:10The duty to cooperate does not include handing over physical equipment within a set deadline
Local network-attached storage (NAS)Accounts not opened in timeThe equipment is on site in Hoofddorp, so bailiffs can remove it directly without BYD's cooperation
Microsoft 365Access was granted too late and was interrupted on Aug 27–28Access must be granted by staff in China; granted at 17:15; restored shortly after the interruption
WeComDid not provide sufficient accessBYD has provided the username and password; the inability to export data is a technical limitation
Source: Hague District Court corrected judgment ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33456
▸ The judge also noted that the bailiff's report did not record that BYD had been told what to do and within what time, so the penalty could not start to accrue.
03 / Litigation costs

Breakdown of the EUR 25,376.57 and what the corrected judgment changed

Items 5.3 and 5.4 of the operative part of the Nov 11 judgment assigned litigation costs and late-payment interest to BYD. BYD wrote to the court that day requesting a correction; on Nov 12, JLR replied that it did not object, and the court issued a corrected judgment the same day, changing the liable party for both items to JLR. The original judgment has been removed from the Dutch judiciary's public database.

Legal costs EUR 25,376.57: lawyers' fees 18,000, court fees 7,062
EUR · payable by JLR within 14 days of notification
Source: Hague court corrected judgment, para. 5.25
▸ Lawyers' fees account for 70.9% and court fees for 27.8%. If payment is overdue and the judgment is served, a further EUR 98 plus service costs is added.
Legal fees: BYD claimed €60,917, court awarded €18,000
EUR · excl. VAT
Source: Hague court corrected judgment, paras. 5.24 and 5.25
▸ Applying the Feb 2026 edition of the guideline fee schedule for IP cases, the court classified the case as an ordinary summary proceeding, capped at EUR 18,000; the amount awarded was 29.5% of the amount claimed.
Three payments of EUR 500,000 covered by the ruling
Same amount, opposite direction
PaymentWho is claiming against whomBasisResult
Penalty tied to evidence preservationJLR to BYDAug 14 interim order: €50,000 per hour for non-compliance, capped at €500,000The judge found that BYD had fulfilled its duty to cooperate and owed no penalty
Penalty for late destructionBYD to JLRNov 11 ruling: €50,000 per hour, capped at €500,000Would not have been incurred had JLR arranged destruction on schedule
Ongoing penalty paymentsBYD to JLRNov 11 ruling: EUR 500,000 per enforcement actionNot incurred if JLR stops pursuing payment
Source: Hague court's corrected judgment, paras 3.6 and 3.9, and operative items 6.1 and 6.2
▸ In Sep 10, JLR said it was willing to hold off enforcement while BYD brought a claim; BYD then filed this case.
04 / Statements and precedents

The CEO's statement and earlier comparable rulings

PB Balaji said on a press call on Nov 13 that JLR does not accept infringement of its intellectual property and will do everything it can to protect it. He added that the evidence secured under the preservation order is no longer needed, because BYD has announced its European sales plan for the Tai 7. In the same report, Autocar listed several earlier cases in which European carmakers sued Chinese carmakers for copying vehicle designs. The table below adds the rulings reported at the time.

Four lawsuits brought by European automakers over lookalike models since 2008
Sorted by year of judgment · Blue background marks cases with JLR as plaintiff
YearPlaintiff and modelsDefendant and modelsCourtResult
2008BMW X5Shuanghuan CEOMunich courtImport into Germany prohibited
2008Fiat PandaGreat Wall PeriCourt of TurinImport into Europe banned; fine of EUR 15,000 for the first vehicle already imported and EUR 50,000 for each one thereafter
2019JLR Range Rover EvoqueJMC Landwind X7Beijing Chaoyang District CourtUnfair competition case: court found 5 features were copied, causing consumer confusion, and ordered a halt to production, sales and promotion, plus damages
2020JLR classic DefenderIneos Grenadier—JLR failed to block the vehicle's sale
Sources: Autocar, 2019-03-22 and 2026-11-13; AM-online, 2008-07-18; Just Auto, 2008-07-22
▸ The Landwind X7 case began at the 2015 Guangzhou Auto Show; JLR called it the global auto industry's first win of its kind. Autocar did not name the court or the ruling in the Ineos case.
Turin court's 2008 penalty on the Great Wall Peri: EUR 15,000 for the first vehicle, EUR 50,000 for each one thereafter
EUR 10,000 / unit
Sources: AM-online, 2008-07-18; Just Auto, 2008-07-22
▸ Great Wall said at the time it did not accept the ruling and would appeal, saying the Peri was independently developed. About 4,000 units had been sold in China by then.
Starting prices of the Defender and two similar-looking models as listed by Autocar
GBP · Defender and BAIC Xingtan 5X are converted Chinese-market prices; Tai 7 is the UK price
ModelMarketsStarting price
Land Rover DefenderChinaapprox. 82,500
Fangchengbao Tai 7United Kingdom47,995
BAIC Xingtan 5XChinaapprox. 15,000
Source: Autocar, 2026-11-13
▸ Autocar says the Tai 7 is the best-selling model in this wave of large Chinese SUVs. Nearly 5 metres long, it entered China's top ten by sales this year.