↑Back to top
European heavy trucks · electric tractor units · total cost of ownership T&E briefing 2026-09-10 (corrected 9-24) · IAA Transportation interview 2026-11-05

T&E estimate: new entrants' electric tractors have a five-year TCO 9% lower than comparable European models

Transport & Environment (T&E) published a briefing on Sep 10, "Are new electric truck entrants serious competitors to European truckmakers?" Using its own TCO tool, it modelled a two-axle long-haul electric tractor (EU vehicle group 5-LH) bought in Germany in 2026, and commissioned Apollo Vehicle Safety to compare payload, range, energy consumption and charging time across 11 electric tractors. T&E policy manager Johanna Braun restated the conclusions in an interview recorded at the IAA Transportation show in 11, and opposed loosening CO₂ limits for heavy trucks. The calculation assumes Germany, 5-LH, five-year ownership, a 9.5% discount rate and residual value; the share figures are extrapolated from manufacturers' public targets, and T&E itself states they are not forecasts.

T&E briefing · 2026-09-10 (corrected 09-24) T&E press release · 2026-09 (corrected 09-14) T&E 2026 heavy truck TCO report · 2026-09-28 Apollo Vehicle Safety model comparison · 2026 Johanna Braun interview · IAA 2026 · published 2026-11-05 ACEA press release · Daimler Truck Puchert interview · Council of the EU 2026-03-30
New entrants' five-year TCO below comparable European models
0%
Germany · 5-LH tractor unit · purchased 2026 · corrected version 9-24
Five-year savings
0 euros
€382,400 − €348,400
Assumed vehicle price gap
0 euros
Europe €265,000 / China €210,000
Projected new-entrant share of all heavy-truck sales in 2030
0%
20,100 ÷ 245,000 units; 24%–31% of electric heavy trucks
01 / Cost breakdown

Five-year TCO of a 5-LH electric tractor in Germany: European truck EUR 382,400, Chinese truck EUR 348,400

T&E's TCO tool assumes five years of ownership, 116,000 km a year and a 9.5% discount rate. It covers purchase price (loan with a 15% down payment), residual value (35% of the pre-tax price), insurance (2.14% of the price), maintenance, road tolls, energy (depot electricity at the industrial IC band, with 20% of energy from public charging), depot chargers, and vehicle taxes and fees. A lower purchase price moves the loan, insurance and residual value together. Energy consumption is the only input where Chinese trucks come off worse.

Five-year TCO of a 5-LH electric tractor bought in Germany in 2026: EUR 382,400 for the European truck, EUR 348,400 for the Chinese truck
Unit: EUR (2026 prices) · incl. residual value · 9.5% discount rate · cost per km in brackets
Source: T&E briefing "Are new electric entrants serious competition for European truckmakers?", p. 5, published 2026-09-10, corrected 09-24. Difference derived from 382400 − 348400
▸ EUR 34,000 spread over five years and 580,000 km comes to about 6 euro cents per km; in road haulage, where margins have long been 1.5%–2%, that difference is already enough to sway pricing.
T&E TCO tool inputs for 5-LH electric tractor: vehicle price EUR 265,000 (Europe) and EUR 210,000 (China), energy consumption 1.07 and 1.15 kWh/km
Shared and differing assumptions for the two vehicle types, listed separately · German basis, 2026
InputEuropean electric tractor unitsChinese electric tractor units
Vehicle price (2026 euros)265000210000
Energy consumption (kWh/km)1.071.15
Annual mileage116000 km
Holding period / discount rate5 / 9.5%
Residual valuePre-tax vehicle price × 35%
InsurancePre-tax vehicle price × 2.14% / year
Financing15% down payment, German loan rate 5.30%
Public charging share20% charge
Source: T&E, 'Are electric trucks cheaper to operate than diesel?' 2026 heavy truck TCO report, 2026-09-28, model assumptions on pp. 25–26
▸ The two vehicles differ in only two inputs, vehicle price and energy consumption, and the Chinese truck actually consumes more energy; the 9% gap comes down mostly to the EUR 55,000 price difference.
T&E new-entrant TCO savings: 12% in first version (Sep 10), corrected to 9% in mid-to-late month 9
Version history of the same analysis · Germany 5-LH basis
2026-09-10
First published in briefing and press release: 12% lower TCO, EUR 43,000 saved over five years
Cost per km is EUR 0.63 for European trucks and EUR 0.55 for Chinese trucks. The press release also states that "new entrants hope to capture up to a quarter of the electric heavy truck market by 2030".
2026-09-14
Press release updated with correction: revised to 9% and nearly EUR 34,000
The reason is that German energy consumption data and private charging prices were updated to the latest figures; the press release text was unchanged, with only a note at the end that two key figures had changed.
2026-09-24
Corrected briefing: EUR 0.66 vs EUR 0.60 per km
Five-year TCO EUR 382,400 and EUR 348,400; the appendix table published the same day revised up the usable battery capacity of the Renault E-Tech T 585 / T 780.
2026-11-05
Braun interview published: "about 10% cheaper"
Interview recorded at the IAA Transportation show; basis is five-year purchase plus operating costs, consistent with the corrected 9%.
Sources: correction note at end of T&E press release (2026-09-14); T&E briefing footnotes 1, 2 (2026-09-24); Johanna Braun IAA interview (2026-11-05)
▸ Change two German input values and the result moves from 12% to 9%; when citing "how much cheaper", always state the country, vehicle group and electricity price basis.
European prices for new entrants listed by T&E: Windrose E700 at EUR 198,000 for the first 100 units; Tesla Semi Standard Range at about EUR 224,000
Unit: EUR 10,000 · Average European electric tractor prices are estimates from T&E desk research and dealer surveys
Source: T&E briefing, p. 3. The average European price is €265,000, with transaction prices for the same model ranging from €230,000 to €280,000; three-axle tractors with full battery packs often exceed €300,000. The Tesla Semi's $260,000 starting price is as converted by T&E; the Windrose E700 was originally priced at €250,000.
▸ New entrants' published prices already sit below the lower end of the range European trucks sell for. SANY says it can undercut comparable European makers by 30%, but it also plans to price higher overseas than in China to avoid anti-dumping investigations.
02 / Model specs

11 electric tractor units: payload 24.4–26.8 t, range 500–700 km, 26–73 minutes to add 360 km of range

For T&E, Apollo Vehicle Safety compared the latest or best-selling electric tractor units on sale or coming soon in Europe: 7 from European manufacturers (DAF, MAN, Mercedes-Benz, Scania, two from Renault Trucks, and Volvo) and 4 from new entrants (SANY, SuperPanther, Tesla, Windrose). Charging time is calculated as the time needed at peak power to replenish enough energy for 4 h 30 min of driving (360 km).

Range and payload of 11 electric tractor units: Volvo FH Aero Electric 700 km, Windrose E700 payload 26.8 t
X-axis = range per charge (km), Y-axis = maximum payload (t) · Teal = new entrants, navy = European manufacturers
Source: T&E briefing annex (Apollo Vehicle Safety, 2026). Payload of two-axle tractors may be limited by rear-axle load; the eActros 600 and SANY e263 are affected with an evenly loaded standard trailer
▸ The newcomers' four models all fall within the same band as European models, and neither range nor payload shows them behind across the board.
Time to recharge 360 km of range: DAF XG Electric 73 min, other 10 models 26–37 min
Unit: minutes · by peak charging power · lake blue = new entrants
Source: T&E briefing annex (Apollo Vehicle Safety, 2026). Most models use the Megawatt Charging System (MCS); the SuperPanther eTopas 600 and SANY e263 charge through two CCS ports, left and right, simultaneously; MCS chargers are currently scarce
▸ The biggest gap in charging speed is among the European models; all four new entrants are under 40 minutes.
Energy consumption per km of 11 electric tractor units: MAN eTGX 0.95 kWh, SANY e263 1.20 kWh
Unit: kWh/km · sorted low to high · teal = new entrants
Source: T&E briefing annex (Apollo Vehicle Safety, 2026). T&E says European makers are generally more energy-efficient among two-axle tractors, while three-axle tractors have longer bodies and lower drag
▸ Energy consumption is the only metric where new entrants are slightly weaker, consistent in direction with the TCO tool's assumption of 1.15 vs 1.07 for the Chinese truck.
Specs of 4 electric tractor units from new entrants: SANY e263, SuperPanther eTopas 600, Tesla Semi, Windrose E700
Payload / range / energy consumption / time to add 360 km of charge
ModelPayload (t)Range (km)kWh/kmmin
SANY e26325.25001.2037
SuperPanther eTopas 60025.35601.1036
Tesla Semi255501.0027
Windrose E70026.86701.0526
Source: T&E briefing annex (Apollo Vehicle Safety, 2026). AVS notes that the Windrose E700's long body may make it difficult to meet turning radius requirements when coupled to a standard trailer
▸ On aftersales, SANY and SuperPanther have partnered with Alltrucks for repair coverage across Europe. Braun says European manufacturers' service network advantage "is still there for now, but will narrow".
03 / Share basis

New entrants projected at about 20,100 units in 2030: 24%–31% of new electric heavy trucks in Europe and 8.2% of all heavy trucks

T&E bases its calculation on 245,000 heavy trucks a year in Europe (vehicle groups 4, 5, 9 and 10). A 43% emissions cut by 2030 equals a 31% electric heavy truck share, or about 75,000 units. If manufacturers make full use of the targeted amendment passed this year, that falls to 23%, or about 56,000 units. The 20,100 units from new entrants assume that SuperPanther (with Steyr Automotive, up to 16,000 units over 2026–2030, averaging 3,200 a year) and Windrose (2,000 units a year assembled in Antwerp, 5,000 in phase two) hit their targets, plus about 3,350 units each from SANY, Sinotruk, Tesla and BYD. Farizon, DeepWay, Skyworth and others are not included.

European heavy trucks and electric heavy trucks in 2030: 245,000 in total; the −43% target requires 75,000 electric units, 56,000 after the targeted revision, with new entrants estimated at 20,100
Units: vehicles · The new entrants column is split into 12,000 units credited to European manufacturers through compliance pooling and about 8,100 additional units
Source: T&E briefing, pp. 9–10. Compliance transfers are capped at 5% of a manufacturer's registrations in that year; the additional volume is calculated as 20100 − 12000, while the T&E original states about 8000 units
▸ More than half of the newcomers' vehicles may count toward European manufacturers' compliance pools. Genuinely new sales are about 8,000 units, a single-digit share of a 245,000-unit market.
Three denominators for the same estimate: 24%–31% of electric heavy trucks, 8.2% of all heavy trucks; Chinese bus makers account for 27% of European electric buses
Unit: % · Bars show ranges or single values · Electric buses: T&E analysis of current sales
Source: T&E briefing, pp. 10–11; the share of all heavy trucks is calculated as 20100 ÷ 245000. The "up to 25%" and "a quarter" cited in interviews and press releases are rounded versions of this estimate
▸ The 25% in the headline and the 8.2% in the body refer to the same vehicles; the threefold difference is only down to different denominators. T&E itself says these are manufacturer ambitions, not forecasts.
Demand-side survey: 41% of truck buyers would consider Chinese electric trucks if 10% cheaper; 32% would buy at price parity
McKinsey 2025 truck buyer survey, cited in T&E briefing · Bain's 2026 IAA survey says one third of buyers may switch brands next time
Buyer and market contextdemand-side data cited in T&E briefing
Would consider Chinese electric trucks if 10% cheaper
41%
McKinsey 2025 survey
Would buy at price parity
32%
Another group of respondents in the same survey
Zero-emission share of new trucks in Europe, 2025
5.6%
T&E press release, double the previous year
Electric share of new heavy trucks in China, 2025
28%
16% of all new trucks
Chinese bus makers in the European electric bus market
27%
T&E sales data analysis
Typical road freight profit margin
1.5–2%
Industry range cited by T&E
Source: T&E briefing, pp. 2, 10–11; T&E press release (2026-09)
▸ The 10% threshold in the buyer survey is close to T&E's estimate of 9%. Whether the price gap lands above the threshold depends on each maker's actual quotes and on electricity prices in markets outside Germany.
04 / Policy comparison

2030 heavy truck CO₂ targets: manufacturers want them tied to charging infrastructure and pushed back three years; T&E opposes easing

The EU's heavy truck CO₂ regulation requires a 43% reduction by 2030 compared with 2019, with the first target in force from Jul 2025. On Mar 30, 2026, the Council adopted a targeted amendment easing the credit calculation for 2025–2029. During IAA in month 9, the CEOs of seven companies (DAF, Daimler Truck, Ford Otosan, Iveco, MAN, Scania/TRATON and Volvo) jointly called for the 2030 compliance deadline to be pushed back three years. Daimler Truck board member Achim Puchert then called for regulatory requirements to be tied to how much charging infrastructure is actually built.

2030 European electric heavy truck demand: 75,000 units under the −43% target, 56,000 after the targeted revision, a gap of 19,000; new entrants estimated at 20,100
Unit: 10,000 units · T&E estimate assumes a 245,000-unit heavy truck market
Source: T&E briefing, pp. 9–10; difference converted from 75000 − 56000
▸ The revision lets European makers stay compliant while selling about 19,000 fewer electric heavy trucks in 2030, a volume equal to new entrants' entire targets. Pushing the deadline further back would ease European makers' volume pressure even more.
Two positions on heavy truck CO₂ deadlines: CEOs of seven manufacturers call for a three-year delay; T&E calls for keeping current targets
Each party's statements and rationale · as of Nov 2026
ProponentDemandsStated rationale
CEOs of seven manufacturers (ACEA)Delayed three years: 2030 compliance deadlineConditions hauliers need for large-scale adoption are at least three years behind; zero-emission vehicles make up only 2.4% of new heavy-truck registrations in Europe
Daimler Truck PuchertLinks regulatory requirements to charging infrastructure rollout"We do not question the targets," but infrastructure is developing much more slowly than expected, and it is unfair to hold only manufacturers responsible
T&E BraunMaintained No further easing of heavy truck CO₂ limitsRelaxation would ease pressure on manufacturers to push vehicles faster and also slow investment in public charging; 70–80% of electric trucks charge at depots
Council of the EUAdopted Targeted amendment on credits for 2025–2029Adopted 2026-03-30; targets of 43% for 2030 and 90% for 2040 unchanged
Sources: ACEA press release (2026-09); Daimler Truck's Achim Puchert interviewed by Welt am Sonntag; Johanna Braun IAA interview (2026-11-05); Council of the EU press release (2026-03-30)
▸ Neither side disputes the 2030 target itself; the disagreement is over whether the deadline should track charging infrastructure. T&E argues on cost, manufacturers on enabling conditions.
Charging and range figures from the Braun interview: 70%–80% of electric trucks charge at depots; models shown at IAA have a range of 650–700 km
Johanna Braun, Policy Manager, T&E · Recorded at IAA Transportation · Published 2026-11-05
Interview highlightsParaphrased from Braun; figures as stated by the interviewee
Electric trucks charging at their own depot
70–80%
Public fast-charging stations are not the main charging method
Range of models shown at IAA
650–700 km
Most applications can run a full shift without recharging
Five-year purchase plus operating cost gap
Approx. 10%
Consistent with corrected 9%
Market share target for new entrants
Up to 25%
Braun stresses this is a manufacturer ambition, not a forecast
Service network advantage
Narrowing
“Still there now, but will shrink”
Braun's conclusion
No more hesitation
Need trust, clarity and a clear pathway
Source: Johanna Braun video interview at the IAA Transportation show (German, published 2026-11-05)
▸ Braun sees claims of inadequate charging infrastructure as a factor dampening purchase intent; according to her data, depot charging build-out affects whether fleets can switch to electric more directly than the public fast-charging network.