On Nov 3, Euro NCAP published ratings for 7 12-tonne urban distribution trucks. The MAN TGL earned five stars. The Volvo FL, Renault Trucks D and Mercedes-Benz Atego earned four stars, and all four of these trucks earned CitySafe. The DAF XB earned three stars, and the Isuzu F-Series and Iveco Eurocargo earned two stars; none of these three earned CitySafe. None of the seven offers lane keeping. Below we compare the seven trucks' sub-scores, the star ratings and CitySafe algorithm under HGV rating protocol v1.20, the effective dates of EU GSR2 and London's DVS, and each batch of truck ratings since 2024.
In this round, Euro NCAP scores three areas: safe driving, crash avoidance and post-crash safety. For 2025–2027, post-crash safety does not count towards the rating. All seven vehicles scored 80% on post-crash safety, so the differences in star ratings come entirely from the first two areas.
HGV overall rating protocol v1.20 (Jul 2025 version, effective Nov 2024): five stars requires 80% each in Safe Driving and Crash Avoidance, four stars 65%, three stars 50%, two stars 35%, one star 20%. The overall rating is the lower of the two; one transfer between them is allowed, up to 20 points.
The MAN TGL's two scores add up to exactly 160 points; after all 9 surplus points from Safe Driving are reallocated to Crash Avoidance, both stand at 80%, leaving no margin for five stars. Losing 1 point in either would drop it to four stars. The Mercedes-Benz Atego totals 133 points, 3 more than the 130 needed for four stars. The DAF XB totals 102 points, 2 more than the 100 needed for three stars. The Isuzu F-Series totals 96 points, 4 short of three stars; even with a higher Safe Driving score, its Crash Avoidance score of 29% is 1 points below the 30% minimum allowed with reallocation for three stars.
The top three were the MAN TGL, Volvo FL and Renault Trucks D; the bottom three were the DAF XB, Isuzu F-Series and Iveco Eurocargo. The Mercedes-Benz Atego, with four stars and CitySafe, ranked between the two groups.
Article 9 of the EU General Safety Regulation GSR2 (Regulation (EU) 2019/2144) requires lane departure warning, advanced emergency braking, detection of pedestrians and cyclists on the near side, and direct vision for M2, M3, N2 and N3 vehicles. Emergency lane keeping is set out in Article 7 and applies only to M1 and N1.
| Item | GSR2 requirements for trucks | How Euro NCAP ratings are scored |
|---|---|---|
| Lane departure | Lane departure warning (LDW)Article 9(2); emergency lane keeping required only for M1 and N1 (Article 7(3)) | 25 points, for LKA / ELK onlyRequires regulation-compliant ESC; LDW not scored |
| Near-side turning | Detects pedestrians and cyclists near the front and nearside of the vehicle and warns or avoids a collisionArticle 9(3) | 15 points, rewarding automatic brakingProtocol text: for this scenario the regulation only requires information and warning |
| Direct vision | Reducing front and side blind spots Article 9(5); new models 2026-01-07, all new registrations 2029-01-07 | 35 points, based on target visible volume≤5.000 m³ scores 0, >20.500 m³ scores full marks |
| Autonomous emergency braking | Advanced emergency braking system (AEBS), Article 9(2) | Vehicle frontal 35 points + pedestrian and cyclist frontal 25 pointsIveco Eurocargo scores 0 points on the latter |
London's Direct Vision Standard (DVS) applies to HGVs over 12 tonnes. Vehicles are rated from 0 to 5 stars based on the driver's direct field of view from the cab, and operators need a safety permit to enter Greater London. From Oct 28, 2024, the minimum rating rises from one star to three stars, and vehicles rated zero to two stars must be fitted with a Progressive Safe System (PSS).
Euro NCAP published its first truck ratings on Nov 20, 2024, testing 9 long-haul models; results for urban distribution trucks were planned for Oct 2025 but actually came on Nov 3, 2026.
| Data | Value | Scope | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| MAN TGL safe driving / collision avoidance | 89% / 71% | Five stars, CitySafe | Euro NCAP 2026-11-03 |
| Volvo FL, Renault Trucks D | 78% / 62% | Four stars, CitySafe, same platform | Euro NCAP 2026-11-03 |
| Mercedes-Benz Atego | 77% / 56% | Four stars, CitySafe | Euro NCAP 2026-11-03 |
| DAF XB | 66% / 36% | Three stars, no CitySafe | Euro NCAP 2026-11-03 |
| Isuzu F-Series | 67% / 29% | Two stars, no CitySafe, first rating | Euro NCAP 2026-11-03 |
| Iveco Eurocargo | 58% / 20% | Two stars, no CitySafe | Euro NCAP 2026-11-03 |
| Five- / four- / three- / two- / one-star threshold | 80 / 65 / 50 / 35 / 20% | Safe driving and crash avoidance, each separately, 2025–2027 | HGV Protocol v1.20, Table 2-2 |
| Pooling cap | 20 pts | One between Safe Driving and Crash Avoidance | HGV agreement v1.20 2.5 |
| CitySafe pass mark | > 45 points and ≥ 3 stars | Maximum of 90 points across four areas | HGV agreement v1.20 2.8 |
| CitySafe four-test total | DAF XB 44.6 / Isuzu 42.0 points | Direct + indirect vision + forward pedestrian/cyclist + nearside turning | Euro NCAP model rating pages |
| Nearside turn score | 15 / 10.5 / 5 / 4.8 points | MAN TGL / Mercedes-Benz Atego / Renault Trucks D / Volvo FL, max score 15 | Euro NCAP model rating pages |
| Truck restraint systems / full-vehicle crash | 2028 / 2031 | Included in rating / planned | Euro NCAP How are trucks tested |
| GSR2 blind spot information system | 2022-07-06 / 2024-07-07 | New models / all new registrations | (EU) 2019/2144 Annex II, note B |
| GSR2 direct vision for heavy vehicles | 2026-01-07 / 2029-01-07 | New models / all new registrations | (EU) 2019/2144 Annex II, note D |
| London DVS minimum star rating | Samsung | From 2024-10-28, GVW over 12 tonnes | TfL / London Councils 2025-03 |