↑Back to top
Euro NCAP truck safety ratings Urban delivery, 12-tonne 4x2 rigid · 2026-11-03

Euro NCAP's first urban delivery truck ratings: 3 of 7 models missed CitySafe, none had lane keeping

On Nov 3, Euro NCAP published ratings for 7 12-tonne urban distribution trucks. The MAN TGL earned five stars. The Volvo FL, Renault Trucks D and Mercedes-Benz Atego earned four stars, and all four of these trucks earned CitySafe. The DAF XB earned three stars, and the Isuzu F-Series and Iveco Eurocargo earned two stars; none of these three earned CitySafe. None of the seven offers lane keeping. Below we compare the seven trucks' sub-scores, the star ratings and CitySafe algorithm under HGV rating protocol v1.20, the effective dates of EU GSR2 and London's DVS, and each batch of truck ratings since 2024.

Euro NCAP press release · 2026-11-03 HGV Overall Rating Protocol v1.20 Regulation (EU) 2019/2144 TfL / London Councils · 2025-03 Euro NCAP · 2024-11-20 / 2026-09-14
City-distribution trucks assessed in this round
0 models
All 12-tonne 4x2 rigids, each scoring 80% for post-crash safety
No CitySafe
0 models
DAF XB three stars; Isuzu F-Series and Iveco Eurocargo two stars
Crash avoidance cap when lane departure score is 0
0 points
Lane departure accounts for 25 of the maximum 100 points; five stars require 80%
Threshold from which London DVS permits apply
0 tonnes and above
HGVs over 12 t gross weight; minimum three stars from 2024-10-28
Score

Scores of seven trucks

In this round, Euro NCAP scores three areas: safe driving, crash avoidance and post-crash safety. For 2025–2027, post-crash safety does not count towards the rating. All seven vehicles scored 80% on post-crash safety, so the differences in star ratings come entirely from the first two areas.

Sub-scores of 7 urban delivery trucks: MAN TGL safe driving 89%, crash avoidance 71%; Iveco Eurocargo 58%, 20%
% · Euro NCAP Safe Driving / Crash Avoidance · published 2026-11-03 · dashed line = five-star threshold 80%
Source: Euro NCAP, results table in "Euro NCAP warns nearly half of city distribution trucks aren’t safe enough for our cities"
The two scores vary to different degrees: safe driving ranges from 89% to 58%, a gap of 31 percentage points; collision avoidance ranges from 71% to 20%, a gap of 51 percentage points.
Ratings of 7 urban delivery trucks: five stars 1, four stars 3, three stars 1, two stars 2
models · Star ratings and CitySafe · 2026-11-03
Five stars
1 models
MAN TGL, CitySafe certified
Four stars
3 models
Volvo FL, Renault Trucks D, Mercedes-Benz Atego, all rated CitySafe
Samsung
1 models
DAF XB, no CitySafe
Two-star
2 models
Isuzu F-Series (first rating), Iveco Eurocargo
Lane keeping offered
0 models
None of the seven models has LKA / ELK
Post-crash safety
80%
Seven models scored the same; no rating in 2025–2027
Source: Euro NCAP press release and results table, 2026-11-03
MAN TGL undergoing car-to-car AEB testing at a Euro NCAP test site
MAN TGL undergoing a forward collision test at a Euro NCAP test site, with a soft target vehicle ahead. Image: Euro NCAP (from the 2026-11-03 press release on urban delivery truck ratings)
Rules

Star ratings and CitySafe algorithm

HGV overall rating protocol v1.20 (Jul 2025 version, effective Nov 2024): five stars requires 80% each in Safe Driving and Crash Avoidance, four stars 65%, three stars 50%, two stars 35%, one star 20%. The overall rating is the lower of the two; one transfer between them is allowed, up to 20 points.

Collision avoidance, maximum 100 points: car-to-car frontal 35, pedestrian and cyclist frontal 25, near-side turn 15, lane departure 25
pts · HGV protocol v1.20 Table 2-4
Source: Euro NCAP HGV Assessment Protocol – Overall Rating v1.20
For lane departure, only Lane Keeping Assist (LKA) and Emergency Lane Keeping (ELK) score points; the legally mandated Lane Departure Warning (LDW) earns none. Seven trucks lack lane keeping, leaving only 75 crash avoidance points available.
CitySafe combined score across four tests for 7 trucks: MAN TGL 82.6 points, DAF XB 44.6 points, Iveco Eurocargo 23.2 points
Points · direct vision 35 + indirect vision 15 + forward pedestrian/cyclist 25 + near-side turning 15 · dashed line is the 45-point pass mark; vehicle also needs at least three stars overall
Source: Euro NCAP sub-scores from each model's rating page, 2026-11-03; methodology from protocol v1.20, 2.8 CitySafe Award
The DAF XB meets the three-star requirement but falls 0.4 points short of the overall threshold, scoring 0 on near-side turning. The Isuzu F-Series scores 32.9 on direct vision, the highest of the seven models, but 0 on both indirect vision and near-side turning, for a total of 42.0, and only two stars — meeting neither criterion.
Safe driving and collision avoidance score distribution: MAN TGL at 89% / 71%, Iveco Eurocargo 58% / 20%
% · X-axis: safe driving; Y-axis: crash avoidance · Dashed lines mark star-rating thresholds; Volvo FL and Renault Trucks D score the same
Source: Euro NCAP results table 2026-11-03; thresholds from protocol v1.20 Table 2-2
All seven points fall below the 80% collision-avoidance line and below the 75% line; the MAN TGL is the only model to exceed 80% in safe driving, and its five stars rely on shifting 9 points to collision avoidance.
Combined score for both criteria: MAN TGL 160 points, Isuzu F-Series 96 points
Points · Safe Driving + Crash Avoidance · dashed lines mark five stars 160 / four stars 130 / three stars 100 / two stars 70
Source: calculated from Euro NCAP results tables and protocol v1.20 adjustment rules
With a balancing cap of 20 points, a star rating requires the two scores to total at least 2 times the threshold, with the lower one no less than the threshold minus 20. Isuzu totals 96 points, and its 29% collision avoidance is also below the 30% required for three stars, so it fails both conditions.
Star-rating headroom back-calculated from the protocol rules

The MAN TGL's two scores add up to exactly 160 points; after all 9 surplus points from Safe Driving are reallocated to Crash Avoidance, both stand at 80%, leaving no margin for five stars. Losing 1 point in either would drop it to four stars. The Mercedes-Benz Atego totals 133 points, 3 more than the 130 needed for four stars. The DAF XB totals 102 points, 2 more than the 100 needed for three stars. The Isuzu F-Series totals 96 points, 4 short of three stars; even with a higher Safe Driving score, its Crash Avoidance score of 29% is 1 points below the 30% minimum allowed with reallocation for three stars.

Comparison

Top three and bottom three

The top three were the MAN TGL, Volvo FL and Renault Trucks D; the bottom three were the DAF XB, Isuzu F-Series and Iveco Eurocargo. The Mercedes-Benz Atego, with four stars and CitySafe, ranked between the two groups.

Average scores, top three vs bottom three: safe driving 81.7% vs 63.7%, collision avoidance 65.0% vs 28.3%
% · simple average of three models
Source: calculated from Euro NCAP results table, 2026-11-03
A gap of 18.0 percentage points for safe driving and 36.7 for collision avoidance, the latter about 2 times the former.
Near-side turns account for about 22% of cyclist deaths in HGV collisions, about 40% in London
% · Euro NCAP study of UK police collision records
Source: Euro NCAP HGV Collision Avoidance Protocol v1.20, 2.1 Introduction
In the same study, nearside turning scenarios account for about 3% of HGV crashes killing pedestrians, and about 6% in urban areas; cyclists are the main victims in turning scenarios.
Active safety on 7 models: near-side turn protection works without indicator on 2, requires indicator on 2, absent or unable to intervene on 3
The turning score is from the low-speed near-side turning test for cyclist protection, out of 15 points, taken from each model's rating page · Other items compiled from Euro NCAP's written assessments · CMS = camera monitor system · Grey = not mentioned
Source: Euro NCAP press release model sections and rating pages, 2026-11-03
The Iveco Eurocargo scored 0 points in all three areas: forward protection for pedestrians and cyclists, cyclist turning protection, and lane departure. The DAF XB has no nearside turning protection at all; the Isuzu F-Series cannot intervene for cyclists alongside the vehicle when turning.
Regulations

Regulation and ratings

Article 9 of the EU General Safety Regulation GSR2 (Regulation (EU) 2019/2144) requires lane departure warning, advanced emergency braking, detection of pedestrians and cyclists on the near side, and direct vision for M2, M3, N2 and N3 vehicles. Emergency lane keeping is set out in Article 7 and applies only to M1 and N1.

Regulatory requirements vs Euro NCAP scoring: lane departure, near-side turning, direct vision and AEB compared
GSR2 consolidated text 2024-07-07 · HGV protocol v1.20
ItemGSR2 requirements for trucksHow Euro NCAP ratings are scored
Lane departureLane departure warning (LDW)Article 9(2); emergency lane keeping required only for M1 and N1 (Article 7(3))25 points, for LKA / ELK onlyRequires regulation-compliant ESC; LDW not scored
Near-side turningDetects pedestrians and cyclists near the front and nearside of the vehicle and warns or avoids a collisionArticle 9(3)15 points, rewarding automatic brakingProtocol text: for this scenario the regulation only requires information and warning
Direct visionReducing front and side blind spots Article 9(5); new models 2026-01-07, all new registrations 2029-01-0735 points, based on target visible volume≤5.000 m³ scores 0, >20.500 m³ scores full marks
Autonomous emergency brakingAdvanced emergency braking system (AEBS), Article 9(2)Vehicle frontal 35 points + pedestrian and cyclist frontal 25 pointsIveco Eurocargo scores 0 points on the latter
Source: EUR-Lex 02019R2144 consolidated text, Articles 7 and 9 and Annex II; Euro NCAP HGV protocol v1.20
For lane departure and near-side turning, the rating only awards points to systems that can intervene automatically, whereas regulation requires only alerts or warnings for these two. The GSR2 blind spot information system (UN R151) applies to new types from 2022-07-06 and to all new registrations from 2024-07-07.
EU GSR2 and London DVS timeline: heavy-vehicle direct vision requirements cover all new registrations from Jan 7, 2029
Start and end dates · lighter segments apply to new types only
Source: Regulation (EU) 2019/2144 Annex II notes B and D; TfL progress update to London Councils (2025-03)
Under GSR2, blind spot information systems took 2 years to go from refusal of new type approvals to a registration ban on non-equipped vehicles; for direct vision, the two steps are 3 years apart.
London

London DVS permit

London's Direct Vision Standard (DVS) applies to HGVs over 12 tonnes. Vehicles are rated from 0 to 5 stars based on the driver's direct field of view from the cab, and operators need a safety permit to enter Greater London. From Oct 28, 2024, the minimum rating rises from one star to three stars, and vehicles rated zero to two stars must be fitted with a Progressive Safe System (PSS).

266,911 legacy permits expiring Oct 27, 2024; 165,926 scattered others
permits · Safe System permits · by star rating
Source: TfL, "DVS and HGV Safety Permit Scheme: Note Giving a Progress Update", London Councils, 2025-03
Zero-star permits account for about 62% of all expired permits, one-star about 27% and two-star about 11%.
Permits issued under PSS conditions: as of Nov 11, 2024, 62,091 permits, plus 41,176 one-off
Permits · by star rating · plus 13 fully exempt
Source: TfL progress note to London Councils, 2025-03
By Feb 18, 2025, a further 27,075 permits had been issued under PSS conditions, bringing the total to 89,166.
2016-09
Mayor of London announces Direct Vision Standard
For HGVs over 12 tonnes GVW operating in London
2019-10
Safety permit scheme launched
Enforcement originally set for Oct 2020, postponed due to the pandemic
2021-03-01
Enforcement begins, minimum one star
Warning letters instead of fines for the first three months
2024-10-28
Minimum rating raised to three stars
Zero to two stars require PSS retrofit; grace period initially until 2025-01-31, later extended to 2025-05-04
2026-11-03
Euro NCAP publishes ratings for 12-tonne urban delivery trucks
Rated models are in the 12-tonne GVW class; DVS only covers vehicles over 12 tonnes GVW
Batch

Truck rating batch

Euro NCAP published its first truck ratings on Nov 20, 2024, testing 9 long-haul models; results for urban distribution trucks were planned for Oct 2025 but actually came on Nov 3, 2026.

Star rating distribution across two rounds: 2024 long-haul trucks, 9 models, 2 five-star; 2026 urban delivery trucks, 7 models, 1 five-star
models · By star rating
Source: Euro NCAP press releases, 2024-11-20 and 2026-11-03
Of the first batch of 9 models in 2024, 4 earned CitySafe; of 7 urban delivery models in 2026, 4 earned CitySafe.
Sub-scores of the three five-star trucks in 2026: BYD ETT 44 Safe Driving 89%, Crash Avoidance 73%
% · Safe Driving / Crash Avoidance · dashed line = five-star threshold 80%
Source: Euro NCAP press releases 2026-09-14 (BYD ETT 44, Mercedes-Benz Actros F), 2026-11-03 (MAN TGL)
Of the three, the Mercedes-Benz Actros F is the only one to exceed 80% in crash avoidance; Euro NCAP notes improvements in its lane departure and cyclist near-side turn performance. The BYD ETT 44 and MAN TGL both scored 89% in safe driving and below 80% in crash avoidance.
Quick reference

Data quick reference

DataValueScopeSource
MAN TGL safe driving / collision avoidance89% / 71%Five stars, CitySafeEuro NCAP 2026-11-03
Volvo FL, Renault Trucks D78% / 62%Four stars, CitySafe, same platformEuro NCAP 2026-11-03
Mercedes-Benz Atego77% / 56%Four stars, CitySafeEuro NCAP 2026-11-03
DAF XB66% / 36%Three stars, no CitySafeEuro NCAP 2026-11-03
Isuzu F-Series67% / 29%Two stars, no CitySafe, first ratingEuro NCAP 2026-11-03
Iveco Eurocargo58% / 20%Two stars, no CitySafeEuro NCAP 2026-11-03
Five- / four- / three- / two- / one-star threshold80 / 65 / 50 / 35 / 20%Safe driving and crash avoidance, each separately, 2025–2027HGV Protocol v1.20, Table 2-2
Pooling cap20 ptsOne between Safe Driving and Crash AvoidanceHGV agreement v1.20 2.5
CitySafe pass mark> 45 points and ≥ 3 starsMaximum of 90 points across four areasHGV agreement v1.20 2.8
CitySafe four-test totalDAF XB 44.6 / Isuzu 42.0 pointsDirect + indirect vision + forward pedestrian/cyclist + nearside turningEuro NCAP model rating pages
Nearside turn score15 / 10.5 / 5 / 4.8 pointsMAN TGL / Mercedes-Benz Atego / Renault Trucks D / Volvo FL, max score 15Euro NCAP model rating pages
Truck restraint systems / full-vehicle crash2028 / 2031Included in rating / plannedEuro NCAP How are trucks tested
GSR2 blind spot information system2022-07-06 / 2024-07-07New models / all new registrations(EU) 2019/2144 Annex II, note B
GSR2 direct vision for heavy vehicles2026-01-07 / 2029-01-07New models / all new registrations(EU) 2019/2144 Annex II, note D
London DVS minimum star ratingSamsungFrom 2024-10-28, GVW over 12 tonnesTfL / London Councils 2025-03